Thursday, March 21, 2013

Poll: Has Hailey Dunn Been Found?



Has Hailey been found?

What do you make of...

The crime scene?  It has been declared a crime scene. 
The cell phone pings?
The mention that it is not where there is cell phone service?  This was an additional wording leaked by law enforcement. 

The fact that it is in Scurry County, as Shawn said?

Billie Dunn's own increase in tension?


What do you think?  Cast your vote, and in the comments section, give your reasoning.  Is it just the location?  Is it behavioral analysis?  Odds?  Is it due to BJD's words?



Is It Hailey?
  
pollcode.com free polls 

63 comments:

S + K Mum said...

I am 90% sure it is Hailey.

BJD has said too much.

She is planning her defence, telling us that SAdkins has threatened her, she hates him, he is poss capable of hurting Hailey.......she is worried!

There's a bus coming and she is going to throw him under it and try to get away with as little as possible.

If it isn't Hailey, she will not be far away from that area.

Red Ryder said...

Wow! I am surprised by the poll results! I voted that I thought it was Hailey. I think more that it's her than not is how I came to my decision. I read a news piece about how the location of the remains had been under water until the severe drought dried up Lake JB Thomas in 2011. This area is out of cell phone service range, and is in Scurry County (where Shawn told police to look to find Hailey). The area has been declared a crime scene! Seriously? How often do they do that when they come across old remains? I mean crime scene with FBI etc. It appears to me that the authorities think this might be Hailey.
I wonder if SA ever fished Lake JB Thomas? Did he have access to any watercraft on it? Inquiring minds want to know!
If this is Hailey I bet SA never imagined all that water evaporating away to expose his crime. I wonder if his bravado and swagger evaporated along with the water? Did he think Hailey's bones would fall apart and be scattered and buried deep in the mud, never to be found?

Juliette said...

S + K mum, I also think the finding of these remains has Billie setting the stage to throw Shawn under the bus; she wasn't saying these things about Shawn when the other body was found not long ago.

Shelley said...

I am not sure yet. But I did find the comment above by S + K Mum that Billie was planning her defense by making those statements about Shawn very interesting.

It could be shes preparing just in case... not that its Hailey since she could still get away with it, but in case they link it to them...

Anonymous said...

The lake level has nothing to do with the discovery of the remains. The remains were well away from the lake.
"Dean said the remains weren’t in a grave, but instead have been found in a mesquite, thorn, cactus-riddled area where authorities have only had access via foot.

“My understanding is the lake had nothing to do with the discovery of the body,” Dean said. “It was away from the lake.”

http://www.ktxs.com/news/UPDATED-Investigators-continue-to-gather-clues-from-skeletal-remains-found-in-Scurry-County/-/14769632/19352194/-/xlli4z/-/index.html

Red Ryder said...

I went to the Texas Water Development Board and read through some documents. Of relevance here is that Texas is in a severe drought which many of us were aware of. Lake JB Thomas was at 3% full capacity in December 2010 when Hailey disappeared. December 2012 it was 0.8 % full and 489 acres surface water, today it was measured again and it is 0.5% capacity and 411 surface acres. I couldn't find the acreage for Dec.2010, but if the difference between 0.5 and 0.8 % (0.3%) is 79 acres of lost water surface then the amount of lost water surface (or growing exposed for SA and BJD) on 2.5% would be A LOT! It would be about 658 which seems to enough.

Anonymous said...

John Young really has his client under control..Not! Wonder what Mr. Young is thinking after she disregarded legal counsel's advice and was on KTXS last night--well after he stated she would not be doing any more interviews?

Give it up...That train's coming! Full speed ahead...Texas Justice!!

Anonymous said...

There are county roads in the location near where the remains were located. County roads are not under water. This area is/was not underwater.

Red Ryder said...

We are getting conflicting news reports about the location of the remains. This is important and I hope they clarify it soon. The article I read was from the Permian Basin titled "Officials End Search For Skeletal Remains In Scurry County" , sorry I am unable to link from my phone but google should take you there :) The writer says the bones were found in the "dry lake bed" "that had been under water until severe drought conditions nearly drained the lake in 2011." I imagine native veg action would take over the area as the water recedes, hence the mesquite and cacti. I do think this body (Hailey or not) was dumped in water by a killer who is now at risk because of the drought. I'll go read around some more and see if I can find more articles either way.

Anonymous said...

The mother has "eye bags"Mothers with baggy eye bags are EVIL.

BostonLady said...

A couple of comments. First, officials have not revealed the exact location they found the remains. It is near the lake but they didn't go into details. They did say they found remains in the cactus, thorns, mesquite.

As to John Young, last year at this time, he did all the speaking for his client. He said that Billie was in "seclusion" awaiting the results last year. And, John Young did start trying to separate Billie from Shawn in the media saying they were no longer in a relationship but then Shawn's attorney came out and said that Billie and Shawn WERE in a relationship. This was before the body was identified as a male.

This year, Billie has immediately jumped into giving interviews and appears to be trying to distance herself from Shawn. Even more, she is throwing Shawn under that bus. Is Billie wondering if Shawn has already gone to LE to make a deal? She should be. I do not believe Shawn will go down on his own for this. If I remember correctly, when he was being questioned early on, he indicated that LE should be looking at BOTH Billie and Shawn in relation to Hailey's gone missing. This was during the polygraph testing.

I would expect to see Shawn and Billie pointing fingers at each other if this turns out to be Hailey's remains.

Vita said...

anyone mind telling this ignorant cunt that i am not shawn, thanks
SKEoD

March 21, 2013 at 12:46 PM

Why don't you call the FBI and ask them who you are ...since your so confused of which Identity you are, depending on which one you choose, to air..within what ever scenario suits you, online.

You have so many names - that everyone is afraid to say it? or they humor you? all know in BTR Chats you run off of how many laptops, or IP's, that you can be multiple user names.

Your language choice tells everyone who you are
- misogynistic -

Your weakness is showing, a bit, just a lil bit ..

Anonymous said...

A simple denial would be sufficient.

Anonymous said...

i gave a solid truthful strong denial many times. you would think that people who are Peter's fan would have picked up on the fact that i am not Shawn by now.

Anonymous said...

I would think Shawn would have better things to be doing right now that visiting blogs. Billie is about to throw him under the bus, he may want to start planning his defense.

Anonymous said...

What I don't understand is ..if he sais scurry county..and he said both of us.. during his poly ...why didn't hey bring him in ..interrogate the bejesus outta him.
Innocent people don't know the where's and the who's...

Anyway, I do think bd is throwin him under the bus...she is prolly preparing. Hating him? Sure you do bd...
Sa? Anyone see or hear from him yet? No nothing? Weird that he wuddnt at least say something.. and now that bds mouth has opened .... he's prolly not happy with her

Anonymous said...

And why would any lawyer have to tell an innocent mother of a missing child not to give interviews? I agree that her statements are prep work for putting this all on Shawn and distancing herself from him. She still thinks she knows best and can lead this investigation and her followers any direction she wants.

Peter Hyatt said...

What better things does Shawn have to do than posting on blogs?

A job?

Billie says he is "MHMR", or "Mental Health, Mental Retardation" (she was trying to sound like an educated professional).

Peter Hyatt said...

If Shawn's family has any sense at all, they will realize that the passage of time has not diminished the risk he is in. They may have become emboldened when he was not arrested for child pornography, or in Hailey's arrest, but the case is far from over.

They should convince him to seek a plea bargain in exchange for testifying against Billie Dunn.

Young is not a stupid man. He may not be a nice man, or a moral man, but he is not stupid. He will have Billie testify against Shawn in order to save her, but the gamble in this is what Shawn has on Billie.

The word "we" indicates unity or cooperation. It is why we do not see the word "we" enter a rape victim's statement, after the rape, because there is no "we" between victim and perpetrator.

Even in describing the break up, Dunn said "when we broke up..." rather than, "when I broke up with him" or "he broke up with me..." which would have showed distance.

His family had him take a polygraph, which he failed. They know the truth and they should consider now, carefully, if this is Hailey, they better act before Billie does.

Anonymous said...

I don't think Shawn will say anything until he knows his goose is cooked. Billie will get loose lips and start pointing fingers and eventually give up information she shouldn't know about.

Anonymous said...

What about Billie saying "as much as we "say" we hate each other-". Isn't this a broken sentence revealing an unfinished thought?

ACH

jen said...

Ive already posted this observation but it is my main reason for feeling this is Hailey, so I'll repost. I believe this is Hailey based on Billie's statement that she 'knows' the FBI is not sharing info with anyone else besides LE, and herself. By saying this she links herself to the body & investigation, since the body is unidentified, yet she still asserts the info is relevant to her.

(Billie is lying about this, because LE has stated no info is being shared with her..but even in lying Bille reveals her belief that this body is relevant to her (hailey)

jen said...

Ive already posted this observation but it is my main reason for feeling this is Hailey, so I'll repost. I believe this is Hailey based on Billie's statement that she 'knows' the FBI is not sharing info with anyone else besides LE, and herself. By saying this she links herself to the body & investigation, since the body is unidentified, yet she still asserts the info is relevant to her.

(Billie is lying about this, because LE has stated no info is being shared with her..but even in lying Bille reveals her belief that this body is relevant to her (hailey)

Red Ryder said...

Peter, do you think these are Hailey's remains? What does Heather think?

Anonymous said...

This is not the first time BJD has put her foot in her mouth, nor will it be the last.

As much as John Young has advised BJD to keep her mouth shut, she cannot help but open her yapper . . . AGAIN . . . but just a lil bit.

Her mouth will eventually overload her arse.

Anonymous said...

Hmm it looks like your site ate my first comment (it was extremely
long) so I guess I'll just sum it up what I had written and say, I'm thoroughly enjoying your blog.
I too am an aspiring blog blogger but I'm still new to everything. Do you have any suggestions for newbie blog writers? I'd certainly appreciate
it.

Here is my blog post; /blog/4574809308/Michael-Kors-Owns-the-Internet-Deborah-Needleman-Apologizes-for-T‘s-Lack-of-Diversity-and-Models’-Salaries-Exposed/5203382

Anonymous said...

Red Ryder, you are correct there are conflicting reports about the dry lake bed. The reporter got it wrong. As Anon 11:35 said, there are county roads, this was never part of the lake area.
The road she was found near is in area off the highway that connects Big Spring (where Shawn's mother lives) to Snyder (where Shawn worked until he quit the day Hailey was reported missing.)
My guess is Shawn knew that area well. I have driven around there on my bicycle and motorcycle and believe me it is wide open and remote terrian. Local anon in the hailey Dunn case

Peter Hyatt said...

Anonymous said...
What about Billie saying "as much as we "say" we hate each other-". Isn't this a broken sentence revealing an unfinished thought?

ACH
March 21, 2013 at 2:17 PM >>

Very wise to highlight this. It means that they say it to each other, even under the context of "we"

Sounds more like lovers' quarrel than anything else.

Anonymous said...

I am always amazed at how rude some poster get. If anyone accused me of being someone I am not, what does it mean? Nothing. I wouldn't lose sleep over it, much less curse at a person on a blog. Good grief, you aren't helping your case any.

Moving on.... I thoroughly agree with the poster as regards that BJD connects herself to this particular body, there has to be a reason for this and my money is on guilty knowledge or forensic evidence. By her simply showing up speaks volumes.

~mj

Anonymous said...

Almost sounds like they discussed "saying" we hate each other to make others believe it. And her finally getting him to move out, sounds like she had to convince him that was necessary also. He may think it is all being done for both their benefits but it is only being done for Billie's benefit. Hook, line, sinker - Shawn.

Lemon said...

The choice of language to slander one of Texas' finest lady citizens only highlights Peter's point on the language of Shawn and Billie:

Sex (body parts) and violence.

This isn't difficult to spot.

Red Ryder said...

Local Anonymous 4:18 thanks for the clarification. I have read the area was only accessible on foot.I take news reports with a grain of salt, especially when they may be protecting a site as in this case. It makes a difference in terms of, if this were Hailey, then that means he did not place her in water. He either buried her in a shallow grave or just dumped her in the open, ugly fields anyone? Was this an area that had been searched? It is so close to Snyder and easily within the time frame for SA to have put Hailey there (if it is her).

Anonymous said...

Could she have been placed in the water, then with the drought, her body becomes exposed and then an animal drug her off to this location and that is why so few remains? Poor child (or whoever this turns out to be) I shudder to think of that possibility. :(

~mj

S + K Mum said...

Does SAdkins have an attorney?

S + K Mum said...

What did SAdkins say / do last year when a body was found?
Did he speak out or stay silent?

Just wondering if there is a difference to this time around, i.e. was he confident last year because he knew that body had nothing to do with him?

(Apologies if I'm repeating stuff already posted).

Anonymous said...

Red Ryder, 4:18 anon here. Also known as local anon in the Hailey Dunn case. She was found in an area fairly thick with mesquite and cacti, off the road. While LE is not releasing the exact location,ktxs flew a helicopter over the scene. The location is not too far off the dirt road and not where the lake bed is. Yes, Very close to Snyder and remote enough to easily dump a body and not worry about being seen. No, according to the searchers the area was not searched. But there is a lot of open country so it would be very hard to search everywhere. Hope that answers your questions.

Anonymous said...

I think u nailed it

Anonymous said...

Oh my I said she. Not good to be convinced the bones are Hailey's. I should have said the remains. My aplogogies

Skeptical said...

If the area where the bones were found is part of the area that was burned by the prairie fires last year, anything identifiable, such as clothing, would have been burned.

Randie said...

The bones belong to a male...I read this a few minutes ago.

Randie said...

http://scaredmonkeys.com/category/missing-persons/hailey-darlene-dunn/

Bones belong to a male.

Anonymous said...

Peter, did you see the newest interview that BD has done.
Phone interview, "suspecting" SA's involvement in Hailey's disappearance.

http://www.newswest9.com/story/21761526/haileys-mom-suspects-ex-boyfriends-involvement-in-teens-disappearance

Juliette said...

Randie, the article you are looking at is from last year. They are writing about the remains that were found near the airport in 2012.

Anonymous said...

Anon at 8:32,
Oh boy! Here comes the bus...

Anonymous said...

sorry, I meant the anon at 8:30 with the link to the article...

Lemon said...

Randie, check your details.

This references the remains found near the McMahon Wrinkle Airpark in BIG SPRING, TX.

Juliette said...

This one is a new link Lemon; it isn't randies. It is from today.

Billie says in this article, '"[He] started [calling] and harassing me and scaring me. I've just seen a darker side of him," Billie said."'


http://www.newswest9.com/story/21761526/haileys-mom-suspects-ex-boyfriends-involvement-in-teens-disappearance

SAlurker said...

Has Hailey been found?

I'm not convinced either way at this point. Thinking 70% yes, she has been found. The other 30% says no.

=

What do you make of...

The crime scene? It has been declared a crime scene.

Anywhere a body is dumped would be declared a crime scene. Right?

=

The cell phone pings? The mention that it is not where there is cell phone service? This was an additional wording leaked by law enforcement.

That is a very interesting part of all of this which makes me think, it is her.

=

The fact that it is in Scurry County, as Shawn said?

I do not know enough about this subject to say either way.

=

Billie Dunn's own increased tension?

Last year, when this happened, she acted very stressed. Now she's acting very stressed again . Can't say either way.

Anonymous said...

That article is from last year, the first body found.

Juliette said...

Randie's link is to the old article but today there is a new article. This is the link to the new article from today:
http://www.newswest9.com/story/21761526/haileys-mom-suspects-ex-boyfriends-involvement-in-teens-disappearance

Here are some quotes from today's article:

"[He] started [calling] and harassing me and scaring me. I've just seen a darker side of him," Billie said.

She said that after they split, he moved back to his mother's house in Big Spring. We went to his mother's home looking to speak with Adkins. Family was inside the house but nobody would answer the door. Nearby neighbors claim Adkins went out-of-state a few months ago for work.

Meanwhile, they say his parents have been getting death threats in the mail and over the Internet. Neighbors also tell NewsWest 9, his mom and step dad are good, honest people and have been shattered by all of this.

Billie claims that lately she's been reflecting heavily on the past, and how strangely Shawn was acting those first few days after Hailey's disappearance.

"For instance, the main thing about him quitting his job and lying to me about it for a week, saying he had a job and then telling me he was fired when, in fact, he wasn't," she said.

Dunn also finds it suspicious that her ex-boyfriend, she claims, couldn't produce his coveralls, a type of work uniform, when a law enforcement requested them.

"The fact that he lied and said they were at work and we already know through video and through his boss that he didn't leave them at work. So, why are they hidden?" Dunn said.

She suspects he may know more about Hailey's whereabouts than what everyone originally thought.

_________

This is a new article from today.

JerseyJane said...

A Big thanks to Local Anon!
It is very nice of you to share your knowledge!!
You are very informative and create great visuals of the area with your words.. Thanks!! :-)

~ABC said...

And the damage control campaign is now in FULL swing. BJD KNOWS it's Hailey.... And here we go. I gotta sing along with all the other FB Hailey supporters.

I hear the train acomin!!

Anonymous said...

but a lot has changed in their lives over the past few months. Billie tells told NewsWest 9, she ended the relationship

She went to a concert with him less than 30 days ago, there's an entry on this blog about her appearance at the concert, complete with a picture that she herself posted on her facebook

finding out that there's been remains found and now we just have to stay in this state of limbo and not knowing for two or three more weeks

What "limbo" when she said yesterday that she and David (her son) were returning to Austin so she could return to work and David return to school?

Anonymous said...

Where the hell is Clint Dunn?

worriedparent said...

Here is a link from the Lubbock Avalanche Journal about another family waiting word on the findings......

http://amarillo.com/news/local-news/2013-03-21/body-found-scurry-county-causes-anguish-new-mexico-family

worriedparent said...

Oppps my bad is from the Amarillo Global news...

Jo said...

This most recent video of Billie throwing Shawn under the bus has not convinced me that she knows this is Hailey they have found.

How does she know the coveralls are hidden and have not been destroyed? Why is it that she is just now realizing how odd Shawn was acting those days after Hailey went missing? The guy was into a bunch of dark, scary things but Billie is just now seeing a dark side to him? He threatened her life before, what could he be threatening now that makes him darker than he was before she moved him into her house.

Jo said...

Oops, meant to say "has now convinced me" instead of "not".

Skeptical said...

BJD can't keep her lies straight. One of her stories from before was that she had washed the coveralls the night before and Shawn took them to work and dropped them off at work the morning he quit. Drugs may have addled her brain so badly by now that she can't remember what she said previously.

Anonymous said...

She certainly DID say that Shawn's coverall work clothes had been laundered and he turned them in when he went to the job site that morning. In fact, I believe she said SHE laundered them herself. I'd guarantee it that wasn't ALL Billie laundered during the wee hours of the night they violently raped and killed Hailey.

There was a LOT of conversation about this at the time; why she laundered Shawn's work clothes when the company he worked for provided laundry services for their employees' work clothes.

I've been here this whole time reading every statement made by Billie Jean; even way before Caylee Anthony, Hailey Dunn and Haleigh Cummings went missing, and reading all of Peter's articles.

Now Billie's got this new story coming out of left field that the one pair of coveralls couldn't be found when LE asked for them? I'd sure like to hear LE confirm this new story! And if that's the case, why didn't they say so at the time?

Further, I do not buy into Billie's story that she has broken up with Shawn. How many times has she said this before? Several. Certainly not entirely, not unless it happened very recently, and even that would surprise me. Not only was there the time she claimed to be broken up with him, then he was caught at her home by officers who came to serve a warrant on him; there was another time she said they were broken up, then was seen with him in a motel room in Colorado City. AND another time, seen together at a concert in a nearby town.

She's suddenly scared of Shawn, has seen his dark side? That's a joke. Funny, she didn't see his dark side back when she was participating with him in his 'dark side' and when Hailey was living in dreaded fear of him, even sleeping with one eye open on the couch; and when she did sleep in her room she would see Shawn's shadow under the crack of her bedroom door late at night, moving back and forth and standing there. Damn right she was scared to death, but Billie knew nothing about Hailey's fears? Billie is a sniveling liar from the pit of hell.

Wasn't she seen at a concert with Shawn just a month ago, even posted about it on her facebook? Shawn apparently is working out of town (wonder where; just in the next county would be 'out of town') and if so this would somewhat curtail her seeing him.

Now she's running scared that this may be Hailey's remains (she knows already one way or the other) and is just trying to cover her tracks with her pitiful and 'eye-opening' stories,lies and whiney 'miss innocent' games.

I just WISH Shawn would speak up. I'd almost guarantee it the public would be a lot more believing and forgiving of Shawn than they ever will be of Billie Jean.

Midnight Lurker

john said...

02/07/2011 - Shawn Adkins - RAW Interview - Hailey Dunn Case.

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Xgd0gEfecZw

Randie said...

I am happy to be wrong about my link. I was bummed when I read that...

So what is the latest update!

Anonymous said...

DOWNLIGHT Pictures (20) ccia (Mario Prada's granddaughter) and then[url=http://www.jppradabagsstore.webstarts.com/#234534][b]リュック プラダ[/b][/url]
with the with opulence products skill Patrizio Bertelli established a business partnership. 1970s fashion circles environmental changes,[url=http://www.jppradabagsstore.webstarts.com/#234536][b]PRADA[/b][/url]
Prada coming the tend of bankruptcy. 1978 Miuccia her husband, Patrizio · Bertelli public receiver Prada and http://www.jppradaoutlet2013.com led Prada close to a imaginative milestone. Miuccia served as the Prada chief architect, through her aptitude of way capacity constantly decoding of the tradition of challenge and innovation.[url=http://www.jppradabagsstore.webstarts.com/#234543][b]PRADA[/b][/url]
Patrizio · Bertelli, a originative entrepreneur, not purely established a Prada worldwide upshot ordering channels as skilfully as the mass product combination, also skilfully Prada historic brand concept and modern advanced technology in the course of the proper combination.
 
Miuccia took more than the celebration,http://jppradabagsstore.webstarts.com Prada is notwithstanding a young brand common in Europe.[url=http://www.jppradabagsstore.webstarts.com/#234534][b]リュック プラダ[/b][/url]
The intergenerational m‚nage without some invention and breakthroughs, it is undemanding to decline. Miuccia looking for different different materials and routine leather, after multiple attempts, from the Known Troops parachute bodily establish in nylon fabric, lightweight, long-lasting foundation, then, "blackguardly nylon dialect poke" a gun and red.