Saturday, April 20, 2013

Blaming The Victim Part 2

Here, Hailey is blamed for disobedience.  These quotes may show why police stated that their stories about Hailey's disappearance kept changing. 

In light of the remains found, and so much else revealed, these quotes from February, 2011, are particularly interesting. Previous quotes:


"Hailey went and disappeared" Billie Dunn said.  Hailey did no such thing.

"She caught her attitudes."

"Hormonal"

"Hailey was 13 when she left."

Hailey didn't "leave."

Mother Still Believes Hailey Dunn was Abducted

from Big Country February 2011
The mother of the missing Colorado City teen believes her child was abducted within a six-block area of their home in the Mitchell County community.

"I think some stranger came in and took her" said Billie Jean Dunn Tuesday afternoon. "That's been my gut feeling from the beginning."

She added that her daughter, 13-yearold Hailey Dunn, could not have been coerced to get in a stranger's car.  "She had to be forced in."

"I told her not to leave the house that day, but she did. She could have been walking to a store, or to play basketball," Billie Dunn added.


Here the victim is blamed for disobedience.  
Note the story line as well does not include the sleepover.  



The girl was reported missing since Dec. 28 and has been the subject of an intense search effort by law enforcement officials and private groups.
But one of the groups, Hailey's Angels, drew the ire of the mother during a Saturday evening event termed an appreciation dinner for searchers.

"KlaasKids and Laura Search Group didn't know about it and apparently weren't invited," said the mother. "We just heard about it and just went. None of our family was invited.
It was held at the Snyder American Legion," and according to Billie Dunn, focused primarily on the group Hailey's Angels.

"It was all about them and not much to do about Hailey," she added. "They showed pictures of themselves at Dunn, in creek beds and out in fields. There was not much about Hailey. They even showed off one of their group's BMW. There were kids in there crying (at the American Legion) and there was drinking going on," she said.

"The important thing for people to remember is not slander me."  Billie Jean Dunn
The group did not invite the Person of Interest. What else anger her?  

A searcher confronted the mother, Person of Interest:  

"She confronted us about leaving saying she had spent two days putting the slide show together. She also told me that she goes out everyday looking for my daughter and that I haven't searched yet. But what she doesn't know is that I just can't go looking for Hailey in creeks and fields," she added.

Note the location of the remains found in Scurry County in regards to this quote. 


"That dinner could have been a really nice thing, but it turned out horrible. I just wonder why it had to be on a Saturday night at a bar."

Note that she held a New Year's Eve party in her home. 

She added that Hailey's Angels had been invited to join KlaasKids in the search at least a dozen times, but have refused to join.
�I used to try to defend them, but I can�t anymore,� she said.
She added that the group also became crossways with her because she hasn't been able to provide money for gas.

"I wish I could give everybody gas money, but I haven't worked in a month and a half. There is an account set up at City National Bank (in Colorado City) for the searchers, but I don't know anything about it," she added.

"I wanted to set out jars or something to raise money for the searchers, but then I was told about the account so we didn't."

This weekend, she and her ex-husband will be in Dallas to address a human trafficking awareness group.

"This should help spread the word about Hailey even further, and there will be a web page set up known as hopeforhailey.com.
"There won't be any blogging where people can talk trash. This will be the only Internet site where you can get mine and Clint's exact words, and we'll keep it updated."

She says she is still in touch with law enforcement officials, but not on a daily basis.
"I call every now and then and they all tell me they'll let me know if there is anything big," she said.

She added that she and her former boyfriend, Shawn Adkins, do hang out together. "We find comfort in each other and he, along with Clint, love Hailey and want her back safely."
Note the need to even have to say Adkins wants Hailey back.  Why would someone even need to say such a thing?  February, 2011


Adkins is the only named suspect in the disappearance.
"But I know Shawn had nothing to do with Hailey's disappearance," she added.

From the Affidvit January 11, 2011



Information in these summary statements comes directly from the affidavits:
 Adkins previously had threatened the lives of both Hailey Dunn and Billie Dunn in February 2010.
 Both Adkins and Billie Dunn apparently held an ongoing, intense fascination with horrific films and brutal crimes. Seized in a box in their bedroom were numerous documents, some fictional and some past crimes, that covered such topics such as serial killers, ax murders, sexual sadistic activities, the occult, sex and death topics, motives for murder and mass murderers ? including the killing of family members.
 Billie Dunn and Adkins hosted a number of friends for a New Year's Eve party at their home  just three days after Billie Dunn reported Hailey missing. Adkins downplayed the party, stating they just had a few friends over to the house to have drinks on New Year?s Eve.
 Billie Dunn volunteered to take a polygraph examination, but when she arrived, she was found to be ?under the influence of narcotics,? and she was dismissed from the test at that time. On her second attempt, the investigators concluded there was ?deception indicated.? After the examination, Billie Dunn was given the chance to discuss and explain ?why she failed the examination.? Officials said she couldn't explain them, and she ended the interview by walking out.
 Adkins twice refused to take polygraph examinations. Then he agreed to a polygraph, but after providing some inconsistent information, he ended this polygraph by walking out. Officials said he failed the polygraph, particularly concerning the whereabouts of Hailey.
During his polygraph examination, before walking out, Adkins provided some positive reaction about knowing where Hailey Dunn is. Indications were that Hailey may be in Scurry County.
Adkins and Billie Dunn made two withdrawals of cash from an ATM machine in Snyder, in Scurry County, at about 6:20 p.m. on Dec. 27 totaling $140. They told investigators the money was for purchasing drugs.
 Numerous statements made by both Adkins and Billie Dunn, particularly Adkins, have been inconsistent, some with initial denials, then admissions, then changed statements.
On the night before Hailey's disappearance, her 16-year-old brother, David, indicated that when he left the house at 9 p.m., Hailey was playing one of his video games in the living room in the house. Based on her skill level with the game, David said he expected her to play probably until midnight.
Adkins told authorities that on the day Hailey disappeared that Hailey was going to her father's house, a block away, then on to a friend's house. She never made it to either location.
Multiple witnesses told authorities that it was uncharacteristic for Hailey to be gone for long periods of time without checking in with her mother.
Law enforcement officials detailed what Hailey left behind at her home: cash, a toothbrush, hairbrush, contact solution, a new MP3 player  and a jacket that friends say she would not have left home without.
The weather was cold outside, but Adkins said he last saw Hailey leaving without the jacket and the personal items.
Officials report that Hailey was well-familiar with the area and that it can be determined that she would not have gotten lost going to houses a few blocks away. No witnesses reported seeing Hailey walking on the date she was reported to have left her residence.
At one point during the polygraph examination of Adkins, he was asked whom investigators should look at, and officials said Adkins responded by saying both of us, referring to himself and Billie Dunn.
One inconsistency in Adkins' statements involved his employment on Dec. 27. Adkins told investigators that he was fired that day, but authorities contacted the employer, who said that Adkins was a good employee and that he hadn?t been fired.
Nevertheless, Adkins left his place of employment at 6:10 a.m. on the morning of Dec. 27 and told investigators that he went straight to his mother's house in Big Spring. However, cell phone records indicate that Adkins' cell phone was in contact with cell towers in the Colorado City area from 6:35 a.m. until 6:56 a.m., during the time when he said he was traveling to Big Spring.
Billie Dunn left for work at 6:20 a.m. on Dec. 27, and authorities said her cell phone was also in contact with the same cell tower during the same time period.










51 comments:

john said...
This comment has been removed by the author.
john said...

"(I) wanted to set out jars or something to raise money for the searchers, but then (I) was told about the account so (WE) didn't."

Change in pronouns..

She added that she and her former boyfriend, Shawn Adkins, do hang out together. "We find comfort in each other and he, along with Clint, love Hailey and want her back safely."

Order is important,she feels that SA comes before Hailey
's father Clint..

Note:Clint isn't given his proper title as Hailey,s father


Anonymous said...

Billie Dunn sure has become very quiet in these last few weeks since the remains were found. At first she was all in the news, and throwing Shawn under the bus. She must have thought they would make an arrest soon, but now she is probably paranoid not knowing when her time is going to be up. No more my FBI guy told me type comments. She has went ghost.

Dee said...

I agree anon. IMO her silence speaks loudly. It is not the norm for her.

Focus on Hailey said...

Peter, by the time this searcher appreciation dinner took place, many searchers were already unhappy with Billie. My search partner and I searched with this group that day, but we did not attend the dinner. From what I heard from other searchers, she stood up in the middle of the slide show and 'angrily' walked out. They had good reasons not to invite Billie, but 'allowed' her to attend. Before this, at the search center, Clint and Naomi were clearly appreciative of the searchers and handed out water to each searcher and said thanks to each searcher. On the rare occasion that Billie showed up at the search center (usually when members of the media were there), Billie was not very nice to some of the searchers...some felt like she looked bothered by being there or like she felt like she had better things to do.

Dee said...

"The group did not invite the Person of Interest. What else anger her?"

She was not invited, she was not the center of attention so I'm sure that blow to her ego angered her. There were probably searchers looking for a live Hailey but I think the majority of searchers saw through her lies and were searching in places a body would or could be. BJD did not want that, Hailey might be found that way and she did not want her found.

Dee said...

BJD also references money a lot. I think she resented that the searchers were getting money to aid in the searches. The money wasn't going to her to do with as she pleased.

elf said...

Contact solution? Hailey wore contacts?

Katie said...

These statements made by Billie bother me and for some reason last night they linked together for me.

On the Bring Them Home show they asked if Shawn has ever taken pictures of Hailey.

Billie said, “No. His mom took pictures of us on Christmas.”

LE took her phone and BD said
"I really wanted it just because of pictures Hailey had put on there of herself"

Billie said "You're the most beautiful girl I've ever laid my eyes on"

Katie said...

Billie said "No" but she added additional information outside of the scope of the question by saying "His mom took pictures of us on Christmas.” And she avoided the actual question or tried to detract from it with additional information.


Billie said Hailey PUT on there of HERSELF. Why the need to point out Hailey PUT them on there? Not took of herself?

Laid my eyes on makes me think of watching something. This said about Hailey. Did she see pictures or watch videos of Hailey?

elf said...

"We find comfort in eachother and he, along with Clint, love Hailey and want her back safely."
She finds comfort with the man who was not only named a poi in the disappearance of her daughter, but also (according to her) brought a memory stick containing child porn/beastiality into her home.
Clint was added almost as an afterthought.
Shawn and Clint love Hailey and want her back safely.
She puts Shawn's love for Hailey in the same category as haileys father.
In April of 2011, a month before this interview, Billie filed an order of protection against Shawn Adkins due to threats found on Adkins cell phone regarding Billie in the note/memo section of the phone. This order was effective for a period of one year. (Ktxs television interview 3/19/2011)
Child pornography found on Shawn Adkins cell phone (ktxs news-reported by channel cbs7 3/20/2011)
She found comfort in being with Shawn.
Pfft.

john said...

On the Bring Them Home show they asked if Shawn has ever taken pictures of Hailey.

Billie said, “No. His mom took pictures of us on Christmas.”

This is a Yes or No question,and requires a Yes or No answer.
Billie goes beyond the answer of no, and tries to explain that there is Christmas photos taken by his mom.

When there is a need to explain it become's very sensitive...

Katie said...

Thank you, John. So it is sensitive too. I just noticed it went beyond the question.

Dawn said...

She was getting donations because she was playing the poor pitiful me role saying she couldn't work to pay her bills because Hailey went and left. There was a rumor that she placed a big screen tv on layaway which she denied doing. I called the store where it was rumored the tv was on layaway, asked about it, said I wanted to check the balance because I may want to pay it off. I was then given the amount owed, when it was put on layaway, what size it was, and when it had to be out of layaway. She was a "tad" mad when I posted all this info and donations dropped drastically

Anonymous said...

Katie said...
Billie said "No" but she added additional information outside of the scope of the question by saying "His mom took pictures of us on Christmas.” And she avoided the actual question or tried to detract from it with additional information.


Billie said Hailey PUT on there of HERSELF. Why the need to point out Hailey PUT them on there? Not took of herself?

Laid my eyes on makes me think of watching something. This said about Hailey. Did she see pictures or watch videos of Hailey?


Statement Analysis is still fairly new in the criminal justice venue. It is not an absolute and we all know that. One of the premises of Statement Analysis is "less is more". When asked if you committed a crime an honest answer should be "no". To elaborate or add a flow of words before said "no" makes you look guilty according to the concept of Statement Analysis. That might fit some people but you cannot paint every person with that broad brush. If a person is nervous for any reason, they tend to rattle on. The cause for the nervousness could be the mere fact that they are being interviewed. People should take caution not to over analyze with Analysis or it can lead them to the wrong conclusion.

john said...

I have been coming here for around 12 month's now,and i wasn't savvy with this case.

Peter's teachings are helping me learn S/A,and im so pleased i found this blog/site to learn.

This one case has so many examples to learn the basics of S/A its quite astonishing.

Im only about 1 maybe 2 % in my journey along the road to becoming a fraction of were other people are in this fascinating science,and its just a shame it has to be employed in these awful circumstances.

Anonymous said...

Blog Talk Radio
Sunday, April 21, 2013

When Compassion & Caring Spark The Courage To Continue

This Sunday morning we take a look at how those who have suffered trauma and crisis navigate from survivor to thriver.

Tune in on Sunday morning, April 21, 2013 from 7:30 am to 8:30 am Pacific Time Zone / 8:30 am to 9:30 am Mountain Time Zone / 9:30 am to 10:30 am Central Time Zone / 10:30 am to 11:30 am Eastern Time Zone…call in and join Angels On Air with comments and questions at (714) 333-3301

Guest: Billie Jean Dunn mother of missing Hailey Dunn

Others: Debbie Coleman Founder of the Cake Angels Foundation and numerous other guests devoted to transforming tragedy to triumph-hear about the value of focusing on your today along with the future and how volunteerism can be extraordinarily therapeutic...JOIN US!

http://www.blogtalkradio.com/missingandexploited/2013/04/21/angels-on-air
-
Survivor to Thriver
Isn't this if you are a victim?
Hailey is the Only Victim
Unless you are BJD " Hailey who"

All will be interested to hear what she has to " say"

Anonymous said...

This statement really jumps out at me and I believe Billie is definitely blaming Hailey.

"I told her not to leave the house that day, but she did. She could have been walking to a store, or to play basketball," Billie Dunn added

I believe this is what happened on Sunday the 26th, not on Monday the 27th and may be one of the reasons that there was conflict between Billie and Hailey that ended in the death of Hailey. Billie's original story was that Billie, Shawn, Hailey and David all stayed home and had a quiet Christmas dinner on the 26th. Early on in the case LE found Hailey on surveillance videos in front of Alco and the dollar store and two girls reported playing basketball with her on the 26th, and an Aunt reported that Hailey called her on the 26th and told her she was afraid of Shawn and didn't want to go home. Another Aunt reported that Shawn sent her nude pictures in text messages on the 26th and she told Hailey to have Billie call her when Billie got home, so apparently Billie wasn't home on the 26th either. There had been tension over the Christmas holidays because Hailey wanted to live with Clint and it was reported that there was even a physical altercation where Billie tried to strangle Hailey a few days before Christmas. Billie said that Hailey looked upset in the Christmas photos because she didn't want to visit with Shawn's family, she didn't want to be there. I believe it was Sunday the 26th that Billie left her cell phone for Hailey and David to use while she was gone for the day and that she grounded Hailey for her "attitude" over Christmas. I believe that when Billie returned home at 8pm Sunday night, she was angry that Hailey had defied her and left the home that day, that Hailey had confided in the Aunts about her home life and fear of Shawn and that Shawn had sent the nude pictures. David was ordered to leave the home at 9pm so Billie and Shawn could confront Hailey and it ended in Hailey's death. This is just my opinion based on what I've read about the case.

let me help you out said...

Billie goes beyond the answer of no, and tries to explain that there is Christmas photos taken by his mom.
---------

i believe that in preparation of the "script" for that show, there were many things discussed. because the host was so inexperienced and unprofessional and had an ulterior motive for doing the show, and tried to include questions from the chat room, it became a mess. they got away from the planned conversation and Billie was having a hard time following along with them. Billie was unsure just exactly what they were asking her and she did her best to get the information out that they had planned to disclose on the show.

her silence now is the cause and effect of you all's running your mouths. think about that.

yes Hailey had contacts, the color change type.

Clint and Naomi were clearly appreciative of the searchers and handed out water to each searcher and said thanks to each searcher...... or they stood under a shade tree drinking the water meant for the searchers, holding their hands out... but yes they did thank each one of them for the money. Clint searched until the donations stopped, just like he said he would.

research a little better Erin, the photo on SA's phone LOOKed like it may be the same person that was one of the porn..... it was not porn itself, it only looked like the same person in other porn.

Jo said...

"I wish I could give everybody gas money, but I haven't worked in a month and a half. There is an account set up at City National Bank (in Colorado City) for the searchers, but I don't know anything about it," she added.

She knows there is an account, she knows it is for the searchers, and she knows what bank it is at. So the only thing she doesn't know is the amount of money in the account and that is what she is upset about, there is money she doesn't have control over. I am sure in her mind, money she hates to see wasted on a search when it could be used for drugs.

Just waitin' said...

BJD will be a guest on Blog Talk Radio? Sunday, April 21, 2013?

Anonymous said...

Jo said...
"I wish I could give everybody gas money, but I haven't worked in a month and a half. There is an account set up at City National Bank (in Colorado City) for the searchers, but I don't know anything about it," she added.

She knows there is an account, she knows it is for the searchers, and she knows what bank it is at. So the only thing she doesn't know is the amount of money in the account and that is what she is upset about, there is money she doesn't have control over. I am sure in her mind, money she hates to see wasted on a search when it could be used for drugs.

What part of Statement Analysis are you using to surmise that "she hates to see wasted on when it could be used for drugs"?

Randie said...

Didn't SA skip information when he said this or am I wrong????

(temperal lucana) spelling

"...one pair was in my locker at my job. And then Monday morning when I went in to work I brought..."

Trigger said...

"I think some stranger came in and took her."

What stands out for me in this statement is "came in."

Is she saying that she thinks some stranger came in and took her "out" of their house?

No Gas 4 You said...

“It was ALL ABOUT THEM and NOT much to do about HAILEY,” (still is to this day)

“She confronted us about leaving ...... " then bragged about all SHE had done.

“That dinner COULD HAVE BEEN a really nice thing, but it turned out horrible. I just wonder why it had to be on a Saturday night AT A BAR." (they were obviously drunk)

...the (drunken mob) group also became crossways with her because she hasn’t been able to provide money for gas.

I wish I could give everybody gas money, There is an account set up ..... FOR THE SEARCHERS <------ there was a criteria to meet.

1+1=2 said...


"...one pair was in my locker at my job. And then Monday morning when I went in to work I brought..."
SA had BD wash ONE pair of his TWO coveralls. he walked into work with ONE and left with NONE.

@ Trigger said...

came into town, not her home

The mother of the missing Colorado City teen believes her child was abducted within a six-block area of their home in the Mitchell County community.
“I think some stranger came in and took her,” said Billie Jean Dunn Tuesday afternoon. “That’s been my gut feeling from the beginning”.

She added that her daughter, 13-yearold Hailey Dunn, could not have been coerced to get in a stranger’s car. “She had to be forced in.”

Just waitin' said...

If Hailey told Shawn she was going to her Dad's first and then to her friends for a sleepover, Hailey would have disappeared before she got to her Dad's house since Clint or Naomi didn't see her on that day. Clint lived only a block away. So Hailey would have disappeared with in one block of her home.

Anonymous said...

Just waitin' said...
If Hailey told Shawn she was going to her Dad's first and then to her friends for a sleepover, Hailey would have disappeared before she got to her Dad's house since Clint or Naomi didn't see her on that day. Clint lived only a block away. So Hailey would have disappeared with in one block of her home


Wouldn't it have just been simpler for SA to say he never saw Hailey? Why provide two destinations to LE that would turn out to be false?

MizzMarple said...

Peter,

Sorry for the off topic - but - Dianne Sawyer's interview of Amanda Knox will be aired on ABC on April 30, 2013 -- which is when Knox's $4 Million Book ("fairy tale") is set to hit the bookstores.

I know you are busy, but I hope you will be able to do a statement analysis on Knox when Sawyer's interview is available.

I will NOT watch the show but I will look for the transcript to provide for you and any other interested posters for analysis.

Knox was "in the news" yesterday, and Hobnob posted an update on another thread here. There were a few interesting statements made by Knox regarding "suicide" when she was in jail in Italy.

Also in Knox's book -- she is NOW claiming that she was "sexually harrassed" by guards, amongst other NEW "allegations."

THANK YOU, Peter !

Just waitin' said...

"Wouldn't it have just been simpler for SA to say he never saw Hailey? Why provide two destinations to LE that would turn out to be false?"

Good point.
Why did Shawn talk about his coveralls? Was he ask "where are you coveralls" Was that information volunteered?

MissT said...

If SA had said that he didn't see Hailey on Monday, Billie would have been forced to report her missing a day earlier and SA needed Tuesday to get rid of evidence before LE became involved. That's my theory anyway.

Ivanna-Anna Lyse said...

Happy 1st analysis-birthday, John :)

allegedly didnt make it there said...

at first NS did say Hailey had made it to her house.

Anonymous said...

allegedly didnt make it there said...
at first NS did say Hailey had made it to her house.


I remember that as well. Didn't NS first state that Hailey did in fact stop by that day but then later recanted the story and said that she got her days mixed up? I have tried to find this online and cannot. Does anyone else have a link?

due to LE screw up said...

try nancy grace transcripts.

Ladyluck WI said...

"I wish I could give everybody gas money, but I haven't worked in a month and a half. There is an account set up at City National Bank (in Colorado City) for the searchers, but I don't know anything about it," she added.

This statement shows the separation of herself vs. the community searchers, that she portrays. She speaks for herself and views herself (and appreciation or reimbursement) separate from the help that is offered through the bank account. Instead of offering the bank account to the searchers as a means of reimbursement and humbly being part of that, she separates herself


john said...

There is an account set up at City National Bank (in Colorado City) for the searchers, BUT I DON'T KNOW ANYTHING ABOUT IT," she added.

BUT:Negates what came before,she says there is an account,and then says she doesn't know anything about it.(oxymoron)

I DON'T KNOW ANYTHING ABOUT IT:Anything said in the negative is sensitive.

IE,Its not about the money.You can be sure its all about the money

Anonymous said...

Yep, I agree John; it's all about the money with Billie Jean.

But,(in the negative!); are there a couple of discrepencies in the article, or is it just me?

I thought initially that Billie Jean said she and Shawn made two ATM withdrawals that night (the 27th?) that totalled $160, not $140, which was all the money they had.

Also, that she said she only had a few relatives over on New Years' Eve, not friends, and they only had a few beers. IIRC, she even had named these relatives. To me, it didn't seem like much of a New Years' Eve party, then Clint came along and said he saw cases of beer going into Billie Jeans' house. Only then did it start to sound like a party was going on, but still only relatives were identified.

BUT, maybe I missed something? Anon 1

Lemon said...

Adkins and Billie Dunn made two withdrawals of cash from an ATM machine in Snyder, in Scurry County, at about 6:20 p.m. on Dec. 27 totaling $140. They told investigators the money was for purchasing drugs.

$140.

http://www.ktxs.com/news/Documents-Point-To-Mother-Boyfriend-In-Hailey-Dunn-s-Disappearance/-/14769632/14683432/-/10am2ycz/-/index.html

Anonymous said...

I find it unlikely that Billy Dunn only covered up after the fact. Instead I expect she was complicit if not the mastermind of the murderous act. Probably the drugs they pruchased together were fully intended for use in drugging -- raping and killing her daughter. Her motive was sexual jeamousy. In this way she felt "in controll" of her lover's desire for her daughter -- she "gave" her to him -- but then in doing so had her killed. This way he was still first and foremost hers -- and their intimacy was only deeper. I actually think it is a similar mentality that Amanda knox had in killing Meridith.

Anonymous said...

there is this whole psychological arena of women realizing and then allowing their men to act on sexual desires outside of their relationship -- but then somehow simultaneously attempting to destroy any emotional bond to that sexual connection --. It can be as "innocous" as porn or as horrofic as incenst and murder.

~ABC said...

let me help you out said...

"her silence now is the cause and effect of you all's running your mouths. think about that."

That is rich! Blame shifting seems to be an epidemic among BJD apologists.

~ABC said...

“I think some stranger came in and took her,”

"came in" is extra info.
Some stranger did come into Hailey's life and take her...

~ABC said...

Ivanna-Anna Lyse said...
"Happy 1st analysis-birthday, John :)"

Ditto John!! :-)

john said...

~ABC said...
Ivanna-Anna Lyse said...
"Happy 1st analysis-birthday, John :)"

Ditto John!! :-)


Thank You...

Anonymous said...

In re your post @ 7:40, 4/20; thank you Lemon for setting me straight on the amount of money ($140) that Billie & Shawn withdrew from the ATM Machines.

I don't know now where I got the figure of $160. I could have almost sworn I read it somewhere earlier on as I remembered thinking at the time that $160 wouldn't buy them many drugs, maybe only one night of dope. Apparently I was wrong about the amount, which bought them even less dope.

Stupid stupid people, will spend their last dime on dope and to hell with the consequences. I guess if anyone else showed up to party with them they brought their own, shared it, and likely shared in the rape of Hailey as well. I hope the b'stards made videos of their evil that night. Anon 1

Alex said...

You must not be from round these parts.....this is what we do...SA! It is NOT new to criminal justice, since the begining of questioning witnesses and suspects, their statements have always been analized and clues searched for..which is ehy you are warned upon arrest that "anything" you say can be used against you. Lawyers have been trying to perfect this technique since forever. If you dont see how SA has revealled SO MANY clues in this case........why am bothering?...

Anonymous said...

That is an amazing comment: "I think some stranger came in and took her". Took her W.H.E.N.?

David is said to have seen Hailey at 9:00 p.m. on the 26th, playing on the xbox. Billie claims to have looked into her bedroom around 6:00 a.m. on the morning of the 27th, saying she saw Hailey's "form" lying on her bed in the shadows but did not go in and touch her.

Shawn claims to have seen her briefly that afternoon (the 27th) around 3:00, 3:30ish, saying she was leaving for Clints' and on to Mary Beth's to spend the night. Liar! THAT would have been the last and only time Hailey was ever seen again IFF Shawns' statement had been true but it wasn't.

So when EXACTLY was someone supposed to have "came in and took her"?

The last time anyone credible (hopefully) that saw Hailey alive was the night of the 26th around 9:00 p.m., and I wonder at times if David can be believed either. Did anyone else see her the evening of the 26th?

We have only Billies' statements about the dinner, etc., however, IFF David DID see Hailey that night, then she went missing the night of the 26th since everything else they've said has been a lie; and was not reported missing until the afternoon of the 28th. Nearly two whole days later. That gives plenty of time for Billie & Shawn to thoroughly dispose of her and all their evidence of the crime.

In fact, the poor girl could have been laying there in Billie & Shawns bedroom, restrained and in the depths of dying for a very long time before they got done with her, (let's hope not!) until she died and they dumped her. After all, they had two nights and nearly two whole days to do it. More likely they killed her the night of the 26th and dumped her the same night, or at the latest dumped her body on the 27th.

Sadly, I don't think we'll ever know the truth about what really happened to sweet Hailey. Anon 1

Anonymous said...

Billie Dunn: "She had to be forced in." Yeah, I'll just bet she did!

Hailey would have had to be forced into the car whether she was dead or alive. Makes me wonder if Hailey was still alive when she was "forced" into the car. Billie has a way of tripping herself up.

Anon 1

Anonymous said...

Adkins is the only named suspect in the disappearance.
"But I know Shawn had nothing to do with Hailey's disappearance," she added.

But I know? From what I have learned here, the mind knows what it wants to say. She admits SA had nothing to do with the disappearance. She knows becuse she was the guilty party. SA just helpped dump the body.