Monday, September 12, 2016

Dr. Lisa Bardack's Statement

Is Dr. Lisa R. Bardack deceptive?

Does she wish the American public to believe that she examined and diagnosed Hillary Clinton, on Friday, with pneumonia and sent her out with only a recommendation to modify her schedule?

Let's look at her words. 

First, consider that Hillary Clinton's handlers and the Secret Service all saw her collapse.  

If a 70 year old has collapsed due to pneumonia, she must be rushed to the emergency room, for they would not know what has caused such a traumatic event, including fluid in the lungs, and so on.  

Yet, there was no rush to the hospital.  

How did they know that this traumatic event did not need immediate professional medical intervention?

A brief scan of main-stream media showed avoidance of the full quote, with two reversing the wording.  Some stated that the doctor examined her on Friday and diagnosed her with pneumonia.  This would mean that after weeks or months of coughing, a 70 year old was diagnosed with pneumonia and not hospitalized.  Outside of questioning medical practice or wisdom, let's look at the words.

1.  Did Dr. Bardack examine Hillary Clinton on Friday?

"Secretary Clinton has been experiencing a cough related to allergies.  

Note the need to explain why Clinton is coughing.  She does not state that she is coughing because of allergies, instead uses the distancing language of "related to" allergies.  The need to explain why is made more sensitive by the distancing language.  

The coughing is where the subject began her statement. This is the priority.  

Note the post of the doctor's video speaks of the cough as related to Parkinson.  

Parkinson sufferers only cough when they try extended talking due to the difficulty of swallowing.  It is a 'choking' more than simply a cough.  

Outside Information:  As a boy, I watched Parkinson's destroy my father.  Watching the video of the doctor relate the symptoms to Parkinson's had an emotional impact and brought back to memory things long forgotten.  The physical and mental deterioration is debilitating.  The loss of concentration, alone, may be noteworthy, but it is also with hallucinations and loss of sense of reality that is predominant.  Adjusting the medications is a balance between allowing the sufferer good mobility while losing brain functioning, or by giving good brain functioning while losing gross motor control. It was  a never ending battle.  

Although "Snopes" lost credibility long ago for partisan articles, I noted that in their criticism they employ deceptive tactics, as is their norm, including withholding information as the doctor in the video was stated to be an anesthesiologist, leaving the reader with the impression that anesthesia was all he practiced.  

The article also targeted the doctor for not examining Clinton.  In the video, he says "I did not examine..."

The article "proves" the allegation that Hillary Clinton has Parkinson's "FALSE" due to various points; all made by the doctor, himself, in the video.  This brings to mind Snopes' report of "FALSE" of "no go zones" in Europe; something European police and governments have long since acknowledged.  

Did Dr. Bardack actually examine Hillary Clinton on Friday to make the diagnosis of pneumonia, which would include various tests (blood) and possible x rays of her lungs?

On Friday, during follow up evaluation of her prolonged cough, she was diagnosed with pneumonia.  

Note "she was diagnosed" avoids saying, "I diagnosed her..." using, instead, the passive voice. 

Passivity is used to conceal responsibility and/or identity.  She does not say that she diagnosed Hillary Clinton on Friday; therefore, we shall not say it for her.  

Note the coloring of blue in the wording above.  This is something known to analysts and readers alike:  the need to explain 'why' when not asked specifically, indicates a very sensitive topic.  Here, it only says a "follow up evaluation" and not a "follow up examination."

This would be to diagnose untested and unseen.  

This also confirms the passivity of avoiding saying "although I did not examine her personally, I looked at her records and diagnosed someone with pneumonia, without seeing the patient, taking blood, x-rays or anything else.  

She was put on antibiotics, 

Note the passivity continues while she avoids saying "I put her on antibiotics" directly. 

Deception comes, more than 90% of the time, with missing information or that which is unsaid, with the intent that the reader/listener will simply interpret the meaning instead.  

Who put her on antibiotics?  The subject does not tell us.  The subject does not take responsibility for the antibiotics.  Why withhold this information?  Why not say, "I put her on...?"

Note:  most people do not like to lie directly.  

She was "put on" and not "prescribed" antibiotics.  What does this mean? What, in the subject's own personal subjective dictionary, does this mean?

and advised to rest and modify her schedule.  

With the prolonged coughing alone, given her age, pneumonia and hospitalization is expected, however, with the video of her various falls and losing concentration, this would be akin to malpractice; not something many doctors would be willing to risk. This says nothing of a nation of doctors critiquing a doctor who claims to diagnose pneumonia without requisite tests.  If this is the case, expect the press to not report it.  We have only seen a few reporters asking about the location of Bardack on Friday, compared to where Clinton was.  

We are also aware of repercussions for doctors/journalists who question Clinton, narrative or the political elite.  

While at this morning's event she became overheated and dehydrated.  

Noted that it was warm with low humidity in New York and that the "pneumonia" sufferer greeted a little girl.  It is doubtful a little girl could get pass the Secret Service to physically contact Clinton.  

I have just examined her 

Here is where we see affirmation of deception.  

1.  She does use the pronoun "I" in her statement
2.  There is no passivity now employed
3.  The subject takes responsibility for the examination 

4.  The additional and unnecessary word "just" is the key to understanding the statement. 

"Just" is a 'dependent' word in Statement Analysis meaning that it only 'works' as it depends upon something else; the subject must be thinking of something else while using it.  

"I just..." speaks to an element most important in this analysis:

The element of Time.  

Question:  What is related to the element of timing within the statement?
Answer:  When Hillary Clinton was diagnosed with pneumonia. 

The element of timing is where the sensitivity lies.  Unless Dr. Lisa Bardack wishes to say "I diagnosed Hillary Clinton", we cannot say it for her.  That would then lead some outside main stream media to ask, "What state were you in on Friday?" and "who is the doctor that caught Hillary Clinton falling, rubbed her back and told her to keep talking as she lost her bearings...?" and so on.  

and she is now re-hydrated and recovering nicely."

If a candidate has an illness that will impact job performance, the candidate should consider the needs of the nation above her own.  If a candidate has a debilitating illness, it is long known by those around her, making the deception both broad and acute.  This would indicate that even within the party and early debates, it would have been impossible to hide the serious medical condition from which Clinton suffers.  

This is particularly interesting for Statement Analysis in recognizing how often Hillary Clinton has employed the word "conspiracy" in her statements.  

In what has become routine within media, deception must still be discerned as truth must trump narrative.  

In wanting to know the truth, is the reader reduced to being "deplorable"; unworthy of an opinion? 

Analysis Conclusion:

Dr. Lisa Bardack deliberately attempts to deceive the public in her statement, without a "technical lie."

"I did not have sexual relations with that woman, Ms. Lewinsky" is technically true, but its intent was to deceive.  Deception is not seen in error, broken promises, or in changed viewpoints.  Deception is seen in intent. Clinton reminded Monica Lewinsky that "sexual relations means intercourse..."

Where most of us would be terrified to lie under oath, even privately, here is one emboldened to the point where lying to 300 million Americans came with ease.  

His meeting with Loretta Lynch was reported deceptively, as well, and continued to undermine American confidence in the rule of law.  

'The grand jury has finished and there is no indictment ...' led the American people to believe that the grand jury who heard the case against John and Patsy Ramsey did not find evidence to indict. 

They did. 

They indicted the Ramseys in the death of Jonbenet by "child abuse."

It was only that Alex Hunter, fearing the private attorneys he would have to face before the nation, refused to sign it.  Hunter deceived the American people while being technically truthful.

Simple state workers who inadvertently forward an email with a client's name on it, outside the state system, would not only lose their job, but their social work license, and could be subject to prosecution. A soldier sent a simple email (one), while yet another took a photo and although he had no connection to terrorism, he may spend a year in prison.  

Such is the case of much within deception. 

Lies have consequences...sometimes deadly.  

There are dead policemen today because of "hands up don't shoot" fabrication.  Heather MacDonald had the courage to post the truth using statistics.  

A commander-in-chief who's felonious crimes may rival the breadth of Herman Goering, is unfathomable.  To factor in a Parkinson's like 'dementia' of one who "cannot remember" setting up an expensive and  sophisticated private server to circumvent laws and who "cannot remember" deleting thousands of emails (about yoga) and who used state-of-the-art software to make sure the deleted emails cannot be recovered...

may hold the most powerful position in the world.  

It matters.  

It matters that lies flow easier than the truth and that all those around her, including media, will lie as well.  


The Sheep said...

Plus, her doctor's name is one "d" away from being 'Barack'! Coincidence? I think not!

The Sheep said...

I agree Bardack is lying. The question is: is she lying about who diagnosed pneumonia or about Clinton actually having pneumonia?

Statement Analysis Blog said...

There is a need to lie which the press will not cover.

The campaign's first reaction is to lie.

She is not coughing, she is choking. She is literally hastening her own death by placing herself under the duress of a campaign with the necessity of not holding press conferences (she cannot take questions) and barely campaigning.

Worth hundreds of millions of dollars, she is incapable of putting the needs of the country, no less a single human being, before herself.

She is entitled' to the presidency of the United States and if she is forcibly removed, she won't be silent. We may see a scorched earth in politics like never before, including targeting Barak and Bill.


Anonymous said...

In the July 28 2015 letter:
" Mrs. Clinton is a healthy 67-year old female whose current medical issues include hypothyroidism and seasonal pollen allergies"

The problem is with the word 'include'. Because it's not excluding anything. She could have any other condition.

Same thing with " Mrs. Clinton's current medications include.."


" She takes no other medications on a regular basis."

Here the problem is 'on a regular basis'. It means she could take medications irregularly or for instance when she has an episode of a seizure.

I hope that the Clinton campaign will be able to issue an absolute denial that Hillary Clinton suffers from any brain-related diseases. Not just because it seems right now as if something is being kept in the dark and it's important to have the truth about the health of someone aspiring such an important function, but also because otherwise it would be a great personal tragedy for Hillary and her family..

Nic said...

We may see a scorched earth in politics like never before, including targeting Barak and Bill.

Why does this get me all excited and want to buy popcorn? :0)

Nic said...

Anonymous said:
I hope that the Clinton campaign will be able to issue an absolute denial that Hillary Clinton suffers from any brain-related diseases.

Great post. There is only two months (!) left in the race. They are going to "fake it" every which way this side of Sunday.

I just don't know how they're going to manage it if she can't withstand an hour out in public. That's zero stress compared to a multi-hour live debate.

Anonymous said...

How about the fact she's supposedly been diagnosed with a high contagious disease on Friday and yet she's going to all these functions exposing people and 2 days later she's in public at the 9/11 memorial including little children as she was seen hugging outside Chelsea's apartment - what does that say about her concern (or lack of) for others? At this point I don't believe a word that comes out of her/her mouthpieces. The fact that her first instinct is to lie and then finally coming "clean" after everything else fails speaks volumes. She is the most destructive and deceptive person in history next to her husband - I lived through the scandal after scandal after scandal of the 90's and have no desire to go back to that black eye of American history.

Alexandra said...


pneumonia is NOT highly contagious. It is usually caused by a virus which would simply cause a cold in most people that manages to bypass, in a specific individual, the extremely strong defenses the lungs have against letting germs get down into them. Bacterial pneumonia is typically quite a bit more dangerous, however these bacteria are NOT easily spread and are not spread through the air either (as with viruses), and would also (just as with viral pneumonia) need to bypass the lungs' extremely strong defenses against letting viruses or bacteria get down into them. The lungs (in healthy individuals) have extremely powerful defenses against either viruses or bacteria getting into them, because it is a very dangerous, and frequently deadly situation once they do (particularly in 3rd world countries). If Hillary coughs in a childs face, he or she would almost definitely just get a cold.
In individuals over age 65, the lungs' defenses weaken, however in a generally healthy individual over age 65 pneumonia typically presents with milder symptoms, much lower fever, and much less malaise.

Vance Holmes said...

Statement analysis is useful -- but not for making a medical diagnosis.

Anonymous said...

The problem is not that Hillary Clinton has pneumonia. That in itself would probably something that the campaign probably could be overcome. The problem is that the Clinton campaign took two days to come foreward with that news, that there's still a lot of questions about that delay. Why the story about overheating, why saying she's feeling great while she has pneumonia all along, why not go to the hospital instead of going to her daughters house. And frankly what else is being kept under wraps considering her earlier lapses caught on video and her entourage/detail seeming to expect these kinds of things.

Elizabeth said...

Hillary does not have Parkinsons, she is in the early stages of Alzheimers disease.

That is the reason she continues this hopeless campaign. She doesn't know or think that she is ill.

Anonymous said...

It's patently obvious she is not fit (health) for office or in any capacity, let alone, president.

The question is, why on earth is she still, or allowed to, carry on campaigning and making public appearances. She is not a well women. Politics aside. It's difficult to watch her. When all i want to do, is tell, whomever thinks she is ok to appear... get a grip, and take her home and look after her.

That's me, though. It pains me to watch!

Lis said...

Can the doctor speak freely, or are they given a script they must follow?

It's hard to imagine that a person with Parkinson's could get away with doing any amount of public speaking. There are many more mundane health issues that can cause coughing fits. Her collapse seemed more like some kind of seizure to me but who am I?
Not a doctor, lol

Hillary Clinton seems to be a secretive person. She is practically militant about her privacy. In a public person, this can only come off looking like she has something to hide.

Then you have Donald Trump's kooky doctor...

This is the craziest election I can ever remember.

Lis said...

Ah, hypothyroid, anon? That could explain the dry throat and coughing.

Anonymous said...

We shouldnt care what any celebrity does or says about anything. Sports kneelers? Who cares. What do they offer of valuable substance to society anyway? Some are great at the game but they're not heros. Let them kneel and ignore them. A purposeless and empty community over-valuing celebrity.

BallBounces said...

Clinton spokesman Brian Fallon said Bardack was preparing “additional medical records” to be made public “in the next couple days.”

“I can attest that it is the case that there is no other undisclosed condition. The pneumonia is the extent of it,” Fallon said on MSNBC.

* * *

That last paragraph bears analysis -- who talks like that?! Is the first sentence a reliable denial?

"The pneumonia is the extent of it” Extent of what? Previously undisclosed medical issues? Our attempts to mislead?

Unknown said...

Elizabeth, what do you mean she has Alzheimer's? This is downright frightening if true.

I don't like or trust either candidate. There, I said it. I'm scared to say it out loud in public, because people seem to be more passionate about this election than they have in the past. I could be wrong about that, though.

alcohol said...

i bet hilary drinks as much as peter does.

Nic said...

Clinton didn't think illness was 'going to be that big a deal'


"Compare everything you know about me with my opponent. I think it's time he met the same level of disclosure that I have for years," Clinton told Cooper.
"It's really past time for him to be held to the same standards, not just as me, but as anybody else who has sought this job," she said.
Clinton had a cough last week, and chalked it up to allergies -- joking at an event that she was allergic to Trump.
She said Monday night she'd thought at the time it was allergies, because she experienced a similar cough in the spring and fall due to seasonal allergies.
"What happened this time, though, was it didn't dissipate, and that's why when I got off the road on Friday, I did go to see my doctor, and that's when I was diagnosed with pneumonia," Clinton said.
She said her campaign didn't publicly reveal her diagnosis because "I just didn't think it was going to be that big of deal."
"Obviously I should have gotten some rest sooner -- I probably would have been better off if I just pulled down my schedule on Friday, but like a lot of people, I thought that I could just keep going forward and power through it. And obviously that didn't work out so well," she said.
Cooper asked about Bill Clinton's remark in an interview with Charlie Rose that she has occasionally become dehydrated and gone through episodes like Sunday's, and how many times that has happened before.
"I think really only twice that I can recall," Clinton said.
"You know, it is something that has occurred a few times over the course of my life, and I'm aware of it, and usually can avoid it," she said. "What happened yesterday was that I just was incredibly committed to being at the memorial -- as a senator on 9/11, this is incredibly personal to me."
"I could feel how hot and humid it was. I felt overheated. I decided that I did need to leave. And as soon as I got into the air-conditioned van, I cooled off, I got some water, and very quickly, I felt better," she said.
"I felt fine, but I'm now taking my doctor's advice -- which was given to me on Friday, that I ignored -- to just take some time to get over pneumonia completely."


The thing is, Trump is falling down, passing out, chocking, coughing, m.i.a., having aides build walls between him and the media, impeding media's ability to tell the story (follow, take pics, video, etc.)

Nic said...


Nic said...

Becky Rose said...
Elizabeth, what do you mean she has Alzheimer's? This is downright frightening if true.

Supposedly Regan was diagnosed with Alzheimer's in office. Supposedly. Tangent: Nancy was known to consult a psychic. Supposedly, he wasn't allowed to make a decision until she consulted them (the psychic).

I don't think you can get any more frightening than that.


Anonymous said...

A 13-year-old Pennsylvania girl who walked to the store to buy a coloring book on Friday was found dead two days later, police confirm to PEOPLE.
Shevy McGiffin of Clarion, Pennsylvania, was found dead in a stream in a forest near her home on Sunday afternoon, Pennsylvania State Police said in a statement. McGiffin, whose father described her in media interviews as “quiet and sweet,” was last seen Friday night at about 6:45 p.m., when she walked to the Dollar General store from home, about three minutes away, according to police. Cashiers at the store saw the girl buy a coloring book Friday night, her father, Andrew Schneider, told
“That’s the last time she was seen,” Schneider told the outlet, adding that she often went to that store. “She is a very lovable girl. She would never run away. She loves her family. She loves her mom. She loves her dad.” Police began searching for her Friday night, as her parents passed out fliers asking for information about their missing daughter, police said. A member of the Clarion Volunteer Fire Department who helped search for McGiffin found her body in a small creek about a mile from the girl’s home, police said. Her mother told police that someone said her daughter had been seen talking to a man in a Buick and that she may have been kidnapped, according to WPXI-TV.

Dad gives expected plea (different last name than daughter).
Haven't heard from mom other than what's reported above.

Anonymous said...

News aaid2 she drowned accidentally

Deejay said...

Goodness Sake! People recover from pneumonia. This is ridiculous. You all don't like her, but the other guy is a crook. This is the worst election ever.

Anonymous said...

"The pneumonia is the extent of it"

It's an attempt to end inquiries.
Nothing else to see here.
Move along.

Anonymous said...


Anonymous said...

Edward Snowden is seeking presidential pardon. Think Pres O will pardon him? Hundreds of drug dealers been pardoned by Pres O.

Me2l said...

For a more balanced and accurate perspective on presidential pardons:

Anonymous said...
Dr Phil September 12 2016: The JonBenet Ramsey Murder (PART1 -

rob said...

Hillary will do anything to get elected president. To be the first woman in office. If she gets there, she doesn't have to stay, she will still go down in history for it. WTH She is a known liar, crook, criminal. No one is surprised. It's just what she is.
Donald has a bit of crazy, it's who he is. He also threatens all career politicians, people may start to want something else. It's terrifying to them. I believe anyone in this has the right to run for office, too bad money is the criteria now. Got to have it or too bad.
We had a discussion at work, repubs and dems, black and white, and pretty much decided it was a choice between the crook and the crazy. Most decided to go with the crazy, it's something we're used to.
Also, we're all interested to see HC in the debates. We also hope the temp will be turned up and lets see how she fares all hot and bothered. Just hearing her voice PO's me.
Just my opinion

New England Water Blog said...

That was not clinton that emerged from Chelsea's apartment looking not only healthy but substantially thinner, it was her body double and there is ample proof of it here.

C5H11ONO said...

On Friday, during "follow up" evaluation of her prolonged cough, she was diagnosed with pneumonia.
--If the doctor saw Hillary during a "follow up" evaluation, this means she had been seeing her previously regarding her prolonged cough, when she did not have pneumonia. She has been seeing this doctor for her cough. on Friday she was diagnosed with pneumonia.
The doctor didn't say that the cough is a result of the pneumonia. The pneumonia is a result of the cough as we have all been made privy to her incessant coughing fits and how she has aspirated saliva into her lungs causing pneumonia. The cough is also another symptom. She is having difficulties swallowing which is another symptom. Add the symptoms up and you have...

C5H11ONO said...

Anonymous said...
Edward Snowden is seeking presidential pardon. Think Pres O will pardon him? Hundreds of drug dealers been pardoned by Pres O.

September 12, 2016 at 11:15 PM

-- If I were to bet on it, I would say he will. There is something in the threat of publishing scandalous and damning emails, but not doing it that screams something fishy is at play here, and presidential pardons may be the price the prez needs to pay as he too is probably in the mix with these emails. Edward and Julian aren't exactly "conservatives" if you know what I mean. They are playing their game and have the upper hand.

BallBounces said...

“I was supposed to rest five days — that's what they told me on Friday — and I didn't follow that very wise advice,” Clinton said."

Who is "they"?

New England Water Blog said...

Bubba's words, now edited in subsequent broadcasts:

“She’s been well, if it is it’s a mystery to me and all of her doctors, because frequently, not frequently, rarely, but on more than one occasion, over the last many, many years, the same sort of thing has happened to her where she got severely dehydrated,” the former president said of Hillary Clinton, who is seeking the office he once held."

Worthy of analysis...

Anonymous said...

New England Water Blog - I heard that exact Bill Clinton quote in his own voice yesterday on the radio when I was driving my car, and I remember thinking "What???" It was so hilarious!! I'm glad to hear someone else noticed it!

New England Water Blog said...

They have since censored it in the lame stream media, removing the "frequently, not frequently, " part allegedly for time reasons, three words...
Lets all wake up folks these are liars with no off button and a scourge on the nation...

Anonymous said...

It's clear "they" would refer to Chelsea's children.

Anonymous said...
Clinton campaign releases additional medical records

Passive language

According to Clinton's physician, Dr. Lisa Bardack, "the remainder of her complete physical exam was normal and she is in excellent mental condition."

Bardack said "She is recovering well with antibiotics and rest. She continues to remain healthy and fit to serve."

Mom of DARK said...

@ Alexandra re: "Anonymous Alexandra said... Anon, pneumonia is NOT highly contagious. It is usually caused by a virus..."

If it were VIRAL pneumonia, you are correct. However, this doctor is stating it is bacterial, for which Hillary is taking antibiotics (antibiotics are only used/beneficial for bacterial infections, not viral.

However, HRC, if she truly has pneumonia, is more likely to have aspirational pneumonia due to her throat muscles not working correctly due to Parkinson's disease (which is why she chokes so frequently). Aspirational pneumonia is not contagious, but is a leading cause of death for Parkinson's disease sufferers.

Anonymous said...

NYT reporting Colin Powells leaked email says Trump is a disgrace... Is he the same colin powell who stated the certainty of WMDs in Iraq with aerial photo proof? Justifying disasterous regime change.

Me2l said...
This comment has been removed by the author.
Me2l said...

One problem we have in America (maybe it's universal) is our tendency to idealize public figures --sports stars, entertainers, preachers, political leaders. We attribute all things positive to those we "love" and choose to support, while the opposition (particularly politically) is pure evil. We are willing to fully embrace any negativity about that which we do not support, creating a climate comprised of rumors, lies, and conspiracy theories.

Anonymous said...

Great statement from Obama:

"I am really into electing Hillary Clinton. This is not me going through the motions here. I really, really, really want to elect Hillary Clinton."


C5H11ONO said...

Back on January 1, 2013 when HRC was diagnosed with a “dangerous blood clot near the brain”, her spin doctor, Lisa Bardack stated with respect to HRC, ““In the course of a routine followup MRI on Sunday, the scan revealed that a right transverse sinus venous thrombosis had formed,” Drs. Lisa Bardack and Gigi El-Bayoumi said. “This is a clot in the vein that is situated in the space between the brain and the skull behind the right ear. It did not result in a stroke, or neurological damage.”
--I am questioning if at the time, back in 2013, if the reason her spin doctor stated in the negative without being prompted, “It did not result in a stroke, or neurological damage” would constitute as a sensitive statement or it was common doctor speak. The link is below. I ask because it is telling that her spin doctor accompanies her everywhere now and conducts “neurological” tests with her as seen in photos from the 9/11 memorial where HRC is clutching her fingers. HRC is seen with Huma Danger behind her campaign jet wearing the anti-seizure prismatic glasses she wore after she left the hospital back in 2013. And because, quite frankly the “fainting” spell was awkward. She stiffened up like a board. That wasn’t woozy, that was syncopy!

Neurological test link:
HRC and Huma Danger wearing prismatic glasses in campaign airplane.

C5H11ONO said...
New spin doctor letter dated 9/14/16. Fit for SA practice!