This is the first in a multi-part posting of analysis.
Please see prior analysis to update on the case of murder victim, Hailey Dunn.
Please see prior analysis to update on the case of murder victim, Hailey Dunn.
Hailey Dunn was murdered the night of December 27 into the morning hours of December28, in 2010. Her mother, Billie Dunn, and her mother's boyfriend, Shawn Adkins, both failed polygraphs and were heavily into pornography and drugs, including child pornography and bestiality.
Subsequent statements made by the mother, particularly on "The Nancy Grace Show" indicated deception, as well as guilty knowledge that her daughter, Hailey, was not "missing" but, in deed, dead. This Spring, her remains were found by a local. Statements made after the remains were found indicated that Ms. Dunn knew that the death came as a result of sexual homicide. To this, the analysis agrees.
No one has been charged in Hailey's murder.
The statements made here were sent for analysis, as the mother continues to portray herself as one looking for justice, and part of a larger community of those interested in justice. Past analysis has shown that the lack of communication from law enforcement is something very sensitive to her, as law enforcement treated her, not as a mother of a victim, but as one suspected in either the death, or the cover up of the death, of her child.
The mother is also particularly sensitive to any criticism, which, at times, has caused her to lash out in rage. These public statements of anger were also useful in understanding the dynamics of the life Hailey was subjected to, as the insults often including both violence and sexuality combined. For the subject, sexuality and violence are organically linked.
The mother has always maintained a small but loyal following.
In the years since she was first reported missing, neither Billie Jean Dunn nor Shawn Adkins have ever said that they did not do it. The mother's boldness grew until the time when it was announced that remains had been found. Her reactions to the yet to be identified remains showed a seriousness that had been previously missing. The location was not a surprise to readers, nor to law enforcement, as all readily knew that they would be found somewhere in the vicinity between Dunn's home and Adkins' place of employment, circling out only a few hours in all directions.
Another interesting aspect of this case:
In most murder cases, there are those who believe the "who done it" factor is open to debate. In this case, since the very beginning, no expert, anywhere, has come forward to say that the mother/boyfriend were not culpable. There were no debates from the 'talking heads', as the case was, as the former city manager characterized it, a simple "a + b = c" case.
Today, the statements, particularly from the mother, are taught all over the country in detecting deception and interviewing, and are useful for getting to the truth, and discerning missing information.
Sadly, justice remains silent, to date, for Hailey. Citizens need to express their outrage and demand justice for Hailey Dunn. This cry for justice may receive traction as readers contemplate what it is the mother is saying to the public, via Facebook.
Billie Dunn has repeatedly insulted and even taunted law enforcement, and has been her own worst enemy. Even her attorney was unable to muzzle her, and it may be that in a trial, the words she posted on Facebook, for example, after she believed that Adkins was seeking a plea arrangement, will be used in the trial, against her, either in the trial itself, or in the penalty phase, should it be adjudicated.
As you read the statements, keep in mind the particular sensitivity of the FBI and local law enforcement refusing to disclose information to her, and the acute need to portray herself as one seeks justice and was a "wonderful" mother.
We recognize that this need, itself, to portray oneself, is a sensitive portion of a statement and one that needs particular attention.
Readers should pay particularly close attention to the topic of communication, as it is worded. The subject (Dunn, the writer) wants the audience to believe that she is in constant communication with law enforcement when the truth is that law enforcement refused to divulge information to her in the same manner that law enforcement would not divulge information to any suspect, until legal Discovery is made for the purpose of a trial.
Being "alone" is also an acutely painful topic to the subject, which it is to many who have guilt. Even in the kindergarten class, there is a need to share guilt, with the psychological sense of 'watering it down' and making it less distasteful. "Everyone was talking!" protests the kindergarten child caught disrupting class, as if it is now acceptable to interrupt a class. Rather than the parent embracing, "Were you talking when you were told not to?" and helping the child embrace the correction, the parent storms off to the school to challenge the teacher's lack of discipline over other children. The end result?
The child is not corrected and the child's teacher is discouraged from teaching the child corrections.
Keep this in mind as you consider the need to "share" from the subject. We have viewed "enabling" responses from her small following, in the past, which mimicked her use of insulting language that combined violence with human sexuality.
Note also the need that the subject has to be in "control"; even over things she has no control over. It is a window into her personality.
Part One: The Statements
Part Two: The Analysis to Follow --this may be in multiple posts due to the length. For now, familiarize and discuss the statements already published on Facebook.
Here is Part One, without analysis, with some emphasis added for readers to consider and comment upon.
Statements made by Billie Jean Dunn 2013 Hope for Hailey July 28 via mobile
Hello everyone,Billie here. I'm awaiting calls for updates on our baby's case, any news really,just to know the case is still very much active. With Hailey's birthday approaching it tears me up to realize it's another birthday without her,another year, I can't let her become one of those many unsolved cold cases. I keep praying for a confession & I ask that all of Hailey's supporters to continue to pray for answers & justice for her too. Pray for LE to be given that break in the case & the patience to wait for it,the clarity to see it. I pray for all of us the patience.
Hope for Hailey Thank you everyone,Frankie thank you,I'm very grateful for any help. I've been feeling helpless lately,I'm failing,I don't know my next move,but I'm talking to many ppl,including other lawyers & I'm taking all advice I can get to figure out who to approach next & how. July 28 at 11:47am via mobile • Like • 3
Hope for Hailey I know there are LE who care for Hailey,I know some only want to make a name for themselves,but some love her,so I know they try,I just wish I got regular updates & at the least returned messages to me & ppl who call on my behalf.
July 28 at 11:49am via mobile • Like • 2 Hope for Hailey I feel like he has a dangerous side to him,that I seen everytime I asked him to leave. I was also told things a year ago by LE that has truly made me disgusted with him. I know media portrayed ppl in a negative light,myself included,so that's not what I'm going on. For a while now I have believed him a possibility,I don't want to get into it too much on this page,but he is someone I despise with everything in me & I believe he is a monster in disguise from even his own family & I do have reasons. I'm friends with all my exes except him,so that's not it either.
July 28 at 11:58am via mobile • Like • 4 Hope for Hailey I heard about this,of course not from LE,I also reported problems MONTHS before she went missing,even after she went missing I brought it up again,but it wasn't taken seriously,the man we seen in our carport (by Haileys bedroom door) doesn't fit that description,however it was dark at 1 a.m July 28 at 12:09pm via mobile • Like • 1 • •
Hope for Hailey Thank you. I was never questioned about it pamela,but I did tell them & even had to call them at one night. July 28 at 12:16pm via mobile • Like
Hope for Hailey There are so many possibilities & coincidences everywhere,that I just don't know what to do,I get uncomfortable,I don't want to start a bash session against anyone. I just know I want my daughter back & I want to know 100% who abducted & murdered her & I want them punished! And not only that,if they did it once(which we don't even know that) they can do it again. July 28 at 12:22pm via mobile • Like • 1
Hope for Hailey Thank you Holly & Ester also,just keep praying,we can't lose faith in that,someone has got to come through for Hailey! It's such a dilemma what do you do,push LE & they possibly arrest the wrong person,or they can't get a conviction on the right person for lack of evidence & poor handling of the case??? I try to trust they doing everything necessary,that's what they tell me when we do talk,I just wish we talked more. July 28 at 12:32pm via mobile • Like • 2
August 4 Hoping our Hope For Hailey families are having a nice Sunday. I've decided I need contacts to touch base often with in EACH dept involved in our case, hoping to be able to bring updates & news for us soon. Of course at the top of my list- who & why & what. I want LE to know every detail, however I only want minimal on what,just would like to know it was quick & painless for Hailey. I've been told by several LE I won't be told until I get her back. Texas Rangers are over what's going on with Hailey's remains & them being released, so i'll be bugging them this week again, as well as following up with my ccpd contact who's investigating a tip passed to them last week. Kelsey Rivera did promise me that Hailey still is & will remain a priority for them. Let's keep praying for a confession. Please call tips to Snyder LE @ 325-573-3351.
Hope for Hailey August 11, via mobile
Hello ago again hope for Hailey family,just want to let you know we appreciate your devotion to Hailey. With her birthday around the corner & the realization that she's gone still so recent,it's be hard to talk,I guess it's been a lot harder since the DNA match. Wanting to know what happend,why,why there's not an arrest,why I haven't got her remains back is all I think about,sometimes I need a little reassurance. When LE explains things,I understand a little better. To me,being mom,it seems they've had her long enough,but really it's not been long,many different departments continue to investigate daily. There's a multitude of evidence to be processed. We want to be 100% sure they have the baby killer,not 95%. They get slowed down when ppl call in bogus tips,this continues to be a problem. They get slowed down when a "wack-o" calls in just to say " I seen Billie having icecream with her nephew". Yes. They also explained that ALL tips are investigated,if someone calls in a tip,demanding a call back after its looked into,if you're not related to Hailey,not needed for anything,they won't call you back. That is preventing them from following up other leads. They've also learned names of ppl who cry wolf. This explains some people,not related to the case,not getting calls returned,very understandable. This is crucial to allow LE to do their jobs,they've been through the wringer as well,& some of these investigators have come to love Hailey & want justice just as much as the family. Thank you to all of the diligent men & women working day in,day out to bring my baby's murderer to justice,leaving no stone unturned & leaving no doubt when they take the bastard to trial.
• Hope for Hailey Thank you all,your prayers are needed,wanted & your caring/love for Hailey doesn't go unnoticed. Yesterday at 8:36pm via mobile • Like • 2 •
Hope for Hailey I have faith that all our answers are there,they just need put together & made presentable,in a clear manner,for a jury. If this killer(s) doesn't come forward before then,they should not get a chance for ANY type of plea. There's obviously no remorse,send them on to meet their maker. Yesterday at 8:42pm via mobile • Like • 4
Hope for Hailey Holly,i think we're very close to charging someone with murder. I know I have to have faith in that,but from everything Im being told & from different departments,yes soon.